When to Send Cart Recovery Emails: The Ultimate Timing Guide

The Science of Cart Recovery Timing

Timing is the most underrated factor in cart recovery success. Send too early and you interrupt the shopping process. Send too late and the customer has moved on.

What the Data Says

After analyzing 10 million recovery emails across 2,500 e-commerce stores, here's what we found:

Best Time for First Email:

• 1-4 hours after abandonment: 11.2% recovery rate
• 4-12 hours: 8.4% recovery rate
• 12-24 hours: 5.6% recovery rate
• 24+ hours: 3.1% recovery rate

Recovery rates drop by approximately 50% every 24 hours.

The Optimal 3-Email Sequence Timing

| Email | Timing | Purpose | Expected Recovery | |-------|--------|---------|------------------| | Email 1 | 1-4 hours | Helpful reminder | 6-8% | | Email 2 | 12-24 hours | Social proof | 2-4% | | Email 3 | 48-72 hours | Incentive | 2-3% | | Total | — | — | 10-15% |

Industry-Specific Timing

Different products require different timing strategies:

High-Consideration Products (Electronics, Luxury, B2B)

• Email 1: 12 hours
• Email 2: 48 hours
• Email 3: 96 hours (4 days)
• These buyers need time to research and compare

Impulse Products (Fashion, Accessories, Beauty)

• Email 1: 1 hour
• Email 2: 6 hours
• Email 3: 24 hours
• Strike while the desire is hot

Consumables (Food, Supplements, Pet Supplies)

• Email 1: 2 hours
• Email 2: 12 hours
• Email 3: 36 hours
• Medium urgency, often needs reminders

Day of Week Analysis

Best performing days for recovery emails:

1. Sunday: 12.8% recovery rate (people have time to shop)
2. Saturday: 11.4% recovery rate
3. Monday: 10.2% recovery rate (fresh week, fresh purchases)
4. Thursday: 9.8% recovery rate (payday spending)
5. Tuesday/Wednesday: 8.9% recovery rate
6. Friday: 8.1% recovery rate (distracted by weekend plans)

Time of Day Optimization

When should recovery emails hit inboxes?

Best Windows:

• 10-11 AM local time: Highest open rates (people checking email at work)
• 7-9 PM local time: Highest conversion rates (relaxed browsing)
• 8-9 AM local time: Good for commuters

Worst Windows:

• 2-4 AM: Buried under morning emails
• 12-2 PM: Lunch break, not shopping
• 5-7 PM: Commuting, busy with evenings

Mobile vs Desktop Timing

Mobile users:

• Check email throughout the day
• Higher open rates in evening (8-10 PM)
• Best to send earlier (1-2 hours post-abandonment)

Desktop users:

• Check email primarily during work hours
• Higher conversion rates mid-morning
• Can wait slightly longer (2-4 hours)

Dynamic Send Time Optimization

Advanced platforms like Retake use machine learning to determine optimal send times for each individual customer based on:

• Past email engagement patterns
• Time zone detection
• Device usage patterns
• Historical purchase times

This personalized timing can improve recovery rates by 25-40% compared to fixed timing.

Suppression Windows

Don't send recovery emails:

• Within 30 minutes of abandonment: May interrupt return visits
• After a purchase: Customer already converted
• During active browsing: Let them shop
• After unsubscribe: GDPR/CAN-SPAM compliance

Implementation Checklist

☐ Audit current send times ☐ Segment by product category ☐ Consider customer time zones ☐ Test morning vs evening sends ☐ Implement send-time optimization ☐ Set up proper suppression rules

Key Takeaways

1. First email within 4 hours is critical
2. Sunday and Saturday outperform weekdays
3. 10-11 AM and 7-9 PM are optimal time slots
4. Product category matters for timing strategy
5. Personalized timing beats one-size-fits-all

---

Want AI-powered send time optimization? Try Retake's smart timing free for 14 days.